Cashless Islamabad: A Deadline Without The Infrastructure

Islamabad’s cashless deadline has arrived before the government has reconciled its merchant figures, published its independent review or shown that payments will keep working when the network does not

Cashless Islamabad: A Deadline Without The Infrastructure

The Interior Ministry has shut down mobile data in the capital during security emergencies. It is now overseeing a plan to make Islamabad “fully cashless”. That raises an obvious question: what happens at the pharmacy, petrol station or government counter when the signal disappears? The timetable is brisk. On November 13, officials announced that the Capital Development Authority and Islamabad Capital Territory administration would stop taking cash after November 30. Every merchant is to be connected to digital payments by December 31. Officials say 26,000 merchants are already connected.

There is a good case for expanding digital payments. Raast offers cheap, instant transfers across banks and wallets. Electronic records can curb small leakages, make civic payments less cumbersome and give small businesses a financial history. Few people will miss repeated visits to public offices, handwritten receipts or the petty middlemen who thrive around cash counters. The concern is the order in which the government is doing this. A useful payment option is being turned into a deadline while some basic questions remain unsettled.

Take the merchant count. In November 2025, the CDA reported that more than 39,000 vendors and shopkeepers had joined the system. The figure now being cited is 26,000. Perhaps the earlier number included duplicate registrations or businesses that never became active. Perhaps the two counts cover different categories. Either way, the public has not been given an explanation. The timing makes that gap harder to dismiss. On November 12, just one day before the Islamabad deadline was announced, the federal Cashless Pakistan Committee was still asking officials to refine the Prime Minister’s dashboard so it would capture transaction values and unique account users. In plain terms, the measurement system was still being revised when the deadline was set.

There is also the independent review commissioned to examine the initiative’s targets, data and inclusiveness. An official statement said the final report and recommendations would be presented in November 2026. No final report was publicly available on November 14. It may exist inside government, but a report that cannot be examined cannot reassure merchants and citizens being asked to comply. The words “fully cashless” need clarification as well. Section 25 of the State Bank of Pakistan Act makes banknotes legal tender throughout Pakistan. The announcement clearly ends cash at ICT and CDA counters. For private businesses, however, it says merchants must be connected to digital payments; it does not spell out whether they may continue taking cash, what legal instrument would restrict them, or which services would be exempt. Providing a digital option is one policy. Requiring digital-only payment is another.

Then there is the question of keeping the system running. A National Assembly committee has called internet service poor and noted that power cuts can shut down mobile towers. The government says an offline-payment solution is under development. It has yet to show that the system can withstand congestion, a power failure or a deliberate network suspension.

Cash still has a job. It works without electricity, mobile data, a charged phone or an intermediary’s approval. Its value is much like that of a fire extinguisher: most visible on the day the normal system fails.

The capital, moreover, is not the uniformly connected metropolis imagined in official presentations. The 2023 census recorded 2.36 million residents, 53 percent of them in officially rural areas. A phone somewhere in a household does not mean that every woman, older person or low-income worker controls a smartphone, an account and a reliable data package. Islamabad’s own pilot offered an early warning. At the H-9 cashless bazaar, vendors and customers reported weak signals, slow internet and failed payments. Cash remained in use. Pakistan-specific field research also found that incentives lifted QR use only temporarily. Merchants worried about failed transactions, fraud and taxation. Customers and merchants, meanwhile, each tended to assume that the other preferred cash. Installing a code does not settle those anxieties.

Nor does a digital trail automatically become tax revenue. A QR transfer may be routed through a personal account and is not necessarily tied to an invoice. In Uruguay, rebates produced a 50 percent rise in card transactions but no improvement in tax compliance. Pakistan will still need workable digital invoicing, simpler registration and consistent enforcement. Privacy cannot be left for later. The IT ministry continues to list the Personal Data Protection Bill as draft legislation. A payment record can reveal who bought what, where and when. Before digital payment becomes difficult to avoid, citizens deserve clear rules on who may see that information, how long it is kept and how misuse will be remedied.

Other heavily digitised economies have resisted the temptation to treat cash as an obsolete nuisance. The European Central Bank says digital money should complement cash and is building offline capability for outages. Islamabad can pursue the same resilience without slowing digital adoption. The immediate steps are straightforward. Publish the independent review and reconcile the merchant figures. Keep cash available for food, medicine, fuel, transport and urgent public services until the offline system has been tested. Set clear liability and rapid redress for unauthorised payments. Then judge progress by active users, transaction values, failure rates and complaint-resolution times not by the number of QR stickers displayed.

Islamabad should become a city where digital payment is reliable and convenient enough that people choose it. Until then, cash remains the backup people can hold in their hands. Printing and placing QR codes is easy. Building confidence in the system behind them will take longer.

Sumreen Younas is an emerging legal scholar and final-year law student at Fatima Jinnah Women University (FJWU).